Courts Generally Issue Temporary Restraining Orders Upon Allegations of Domestic Violence
Domestic Violence Allegations Generally Result in the California Courts Issuing Temporary Restraining Orders Pending a Hearing. A Permanent Restraining Order Issued After a Hearing Has Profound Effects on Child Custody Under California Law..
Navigating family law matters, particularly when dealing with divorce, paternity, child custody, and the complexities of domestic violence cases in both civil and criminal court, can be overwhelming. A recent decision, In re Marriage of A.M. & R.Y., by the California Courts of Appeal emphasizes the importance of addressing domestic abuse allegations thoroughly within family law proceedings.
BACKGROUND OF THE CASE: The California Appeals Court published this matter on May 25, 2025. In the case, A.M. appealed from an order denying a domestic violence temporary restraining order (DVTRO)[1] against her former husband R.Y. A.M. argued the trial court erred by denying her request because she made a facially adequate showing of abuse for a DVTRO pending a noticed hearing. The Appeals Court reversed the order denying the DVTRO and sent the case back to the trial court for further consideration of the issue.
This case highlighted the need for courts to explicitly state reasons for denying a Domestic Violence Temporary Restraining Order (DVTRO), especially when credible evidence of past abuse exists. This case addressed the Prima Facie Evidence Standard, the Totality of Circumstances evaluation, and the prioritization of Protection over Procedure.
- These principles mean the courts will generally grant a temporary restraining order until their can be a hearing on the matter.
- A domestic violence restraining order has a profound effect on the rights of the restrained party and the protected party concerning child custody.
- If a California Court issues an order of protection in a domestic violence case by law a presumption exists that the restrained parent may not have legal custody and may not have joint physical custody.
- To learn more about how a domestic violence restraining order effects child custody in California read this article and this article.
- Learn about the July 23, 2025 Decision Which Allows California Family Law Courts to Issue Restraining Orders Based On Conduct Which Occurred Years Ago: In the case X.K. v. M.C. the California Appellate Court stated that a Family Law Trial court may issue a restraining order based on conduct which occurred years ago, even if the the person who applies for the restraining order does not allege any recent conduct which would violate the California Domestic Violence Act.
Read More About the X.K. v. M.C. case here.
At Galen Gentry Law Group, we specialize in protecting our clients through expert navigation of complex family law issues. Our experienced legal team is adept at handling high-stakes cases involving divorce, paternity disputes, child custody battles, and both civil and criminal domestic violence allegations. We are committed to delivering optimal outcomes for clients facing intricate legal challenges in these areas.
If you are involved in a complex family law matter, especially one involving divorce, paternity, child custody, or domestic violence cases, contact the experienced attorneys at Galen Gentry Law Group today. We are here to guide you through the legal complexities with precision and compassion.
Galen Gentry assists clients in Los Angeles and Southern California with issues relating to domestic violence, divorce, child custody cases involving unmarried couples,and the modification of family law court orders. Mr. Gentry has 30 years of experience and help people protect their families and their interests.
Call us to schedule a free consultation at 310 282 7521 or contact us here.