Learn What to Do if Your Ex Files an Ex Parte about Child Custody
I am often contacted by nervous parents who state that their ex has filed (or is about to file) an Ex Parte Application concerning modifying or creating a child custody order in Family Law Court. Often after I listen to their story, I am able to tell them to relax. The most common reason I see unrepresented parties file Ex Parte applications is because the parties do not presently have a custody order.
The fact that the parties do not have a child custody order and cannot agree on a child custody order is not grounds for an Ex Parte Application. A request for orders regarding child custody must be filed and served subject to the rules within the Code of Civil Procedure and the California Rules of Court.
EX PARTE APPLICATIONS EXPLAINED
- What is an Ex Parte? An Ex Parte Application is used for one party to ask the Court for an order without providing the other party (or parties) the usual amount of notice or opportunity to write an opposition. The Ex Parte Application must show there is an emergency such that there will be irreparable harm or immediate danger if the order is not granted.
- Why would someone file an Ex Parte? It is usually filed in family law courts in California to address issues related to child custody, child visitation, parenting schedules or some other time sensitive issue relating to children such as the imminent travel outside the state by one parent with the children.
- What is the purpose of an Ex Parte? The purpose of a request for emergency orders is to address matters that cannot be heard on the court’s regular hearing calendar. In this type of proceeding, notice to the other party is shorter than in other proceedings. Notice to the other party can also be waived under exceptional and other circumstances as provided in the California Rules of Court, the Family Law Code and the California Code of Civil Procedure.
- Do California Family Law Courts routinely grant Ex Parte Applications? No. Often parties file them because they want immediate relief. But the courts can only grant ex parte applications in limited circumstances.
California Rules of Court 5.151 states the court can
(1) Make orders to help prevent an immediate danger or irreparable harm to a party or to the children involved in the matter;
(2) Make orders to help prevent immediate loss or damage to property subject to disposition in the case; or
(3) Make orders about procedural matters, including the following:
(A) Setting a date for a hearing on the matter that is sooner than that of a regular hearing (granting an order shortening time for hearing);
(B) Shortening or extending the time required for the moving party to serve the other party with the notice of the hearing and supporting papers (grant an order shortening time for service); and
(C) Continuing a hearing or trial.
- Ex Parte Applications for child custody cases: There must be immediate danger or irreparable harm. An ex parte custody application should not be brought just because a spouse or parent wants immediate orders. Without immediate danger or irreparable harm, the court does not have the power to make ex parte orders.
The applicant must include child custody or parenting time under California Family Code 3064, it must:
(A) Provide a full, detailed description of the most recent incidents showing:
(i) Immediate harm to the child as defined in Family Code section 3064(b); or
(ii) Immediate risk that the child will be removed from the State of California.
(B) Specify the date of each incident described in (A);
(C) Advise the court of the existing custody and visitation (parenting time) arrangements and how they would be changed by the request for emergency orders;
(D) Include a copy of the current custody orders, if they are available. If no orders exist, explain where and with whom the child is currently living; and
(E) Include a completed Declaration Under Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA) (FL-105) if the form was not already filed by a party or if the information has changed since it was filed.”
- Does the Ex Parte need to be served? Yes.
California Rules of Court 5.167 states:
- (a) Service of documents requesting emergency orders
A party seeking emergency orders and a party providing written opposition must serve the papers on the other party or on the other party’s attorney at the first reasonable opportunity before the hearing. Absent exceptional circumstances, no hearing may be conducted unless such service has been made. The court may waive this requirement in extraordinary circumstances if good cause is shown that imminent harm is likely if documents are provided to the other party before the hearing. This rule does not apply in cases filed under the Domestic Violence Prevention Act.
(b) Service of temporary emergency orders
If the judicial officer signs the applicant’s proposed emergency orders, the applicant must obtain and have the conformed copy of the orders personally served on all parties.”
- Should the other party oppose the Ex Parte? Sometimes. If the other party is aware the application will be made that party should first obtain a copy of the ex parte application and all the paperwork that goes with it. If the person who noticed the ex parte refuses to provide it, this should be brought to the court’s attention.
If you read the Ex Parte Application and decide to oppose it you should do it in writing. Many California Superior Courts decide ex partes without argument or an in person hearing. The Courts often decide the ex parte based exclusively on the application and any written opposition.
Not every Ex Parte application merits a response: Often, a review of the ex parte application reveals flaws that will result in the court denying the ex parte. In which case there is no reason to prepare and file a response. Commonly the facts that the parent finds so compelling are not at all compelling to the court. Imminent danger and irreparable harm are serious and absent a serious reason the Courts will not grant the Ex Parte application.
- Here is a question I often receive from people in cases where the other parent has filed an Ex Parte which was denied: “My ex filed an Ex Parte for a child custody order modification and the court denied it. The court set the issue of custody modification for hearing in the future, ordered the parties to child custody mediation and ordered my ex to serve me with the denial of the Ex Parte, a copy of the Request for Orders for Modification and the order to mediation. What do I do?”
Answer: If you were served with the order denying the ex parte and setting the hearing on the request for orders regarding child custody modification, and your ex’s request for modification you need to file a response on Form Fl-320 and you need to appear. If you receive an order to mediation, you must comply with the order. Here is a link to an article which describes how to fill out the FL-320 and other necessary forms and how to serve the forms and file the forms.
You may be able to appear via zoom. It is less of a hassle than appearing in person. Check your county superior court rules on the court website. In Los Angeles County Superior Court Family Law Cases it is easy to appear via zoom for family law hearings on child custody modifications and other matters like child support and spousal support. Here is the link to appear via zoom. Same for Orange County Family Law Hearings. Here is the OC link for zoom appearances. In other counties such as Alameda and San Mateo if your case is assigned to one of the Family Law Direct Departments, you may need to check the court’s website or the department’s individual webpage for information regarding remote appearances.
If the party against whom the Ex Parte is sought is not served with the order: If you were not served by your ex with the order denying the ex parte and setting the hearing on the request for orders regarding child custody modification, and your ex’s request for modification , then you do not have notice under the Code of Civil Procedure. You do not need to appear.
On the date of the hearing the Court will continue the hearing to a date in the futures and again order your ex to have you served. This actually happens a lot. Especially when your ex is not represented by a lawyer. BUT, if you are ready you can appear on the hearing date and engage in the mediation.
The reader may be asking themselves: “How would the other party know anything about the Ex Parte?”
The answer is the applicant often threatens their ex and states that they intend to file an Ex Parte and armed with the knowledge of the threat the other party checks the court case themselves on the court’s website. Happens all the time.
Summary: Don’t panic if you receive notice of an Ex Parte application. Unless there is evidence of immanent danger to a child or evidence of some harm to the child that cannot be undone the court will not grant the Ex Parte.